How to Invest: ESG and Sustainable Investing

In partnership with

Welcome to How to Invest. In this article:

• Main Feature: ESG Investing: Aligning Your Portfolio With Your Values

• Investment Ideas for All Budgets

• Educational Corner: Understanding ESG Ratings

• Did You Know? A Quick Financial Fact

ESG Investing: Aligning Your Portfolio With Your Values

ESG investing—short for Environmental, Social, and Governance—is an approach that considers non-financial factors alongside traditional financial metrics when evaluating investment opportunities. This strategy allows investors to support companies addressing global challenges while still pursuing competitive returns. Rather than focusing solely on philanthropy, ESG investing recognizes that companies managing environmental impacts, fostering inclusive workplaces, and implementing ethical governance practices may be better positioned for long-term success. This section explores the fundamentals of ESG investing, including its core components, approaches, potential benefits, and key considerations.

What Is ESG Investing?

ESG investing evaluates companies based on three core dimensions:

• Environmental: How a company performs as a steward of the natural environment, including climate impact, resource management, pollution, waste handling, and biodiversity protection.

• Social: How a company manages relationships with its employees, suppliers, customers, and communities, encompassing labor practices, diversity and inclusion, human rights, data privacy, and community engagement.

• Governance: How a company's leadership, executive compensation, audits, internal controls, and shareholder rights support accountability and ethical business conduct.

These ESG factors provide insights into company risks and opportunities that might not be captured in traditional financial analysis but can significantly impact long-term performance.

Today’s Fastest Growing Company Might Surprise You

🚨 No, it's not the publicly traded tech giant you might expect… Meet $MODE, the disruptor turning phones into potential income generators.

Mode saw 32,481% revenue growth, ranking them the #1 software company on Deloitte’s 2023 fastest-growing companies list.

📲 They’re pioneering "Privatized Universal Basic Income" powered by technology — not government, and their EarnPhone has already helped consumers earn over $325M!

Invest in their pre-IPO offering before their share price changes on May 1st.

Invest now before price changes.

_{*An intent to IPO is no guarantee that an actual IPO will occur. Please read the offering circular and related risks at invest.modemobile.com.
*The Deloitte rankings are based on submitted applications and public company database research.}

Approaches to ESG Investing

1. Negative Screening Excluding industries or companies involved in controversial activities (tobacco, weapons, fossil fuels, etc.).

2. Positive Screening Actively selecting companies with strong ESG practices relative to industry peers.

3. ESG Integration Incorporating ESG factors into traditional financial analysis to provide a more holistic investment assessment.

4. Thematic Investing Focusing on specific environmental or social themes such as clean energy, water scarcity, or healthcare access.

5. Impact Investing Deliberately investing to generate positive, measurable social or environmental outcomes alongside financial returns.

6. Active Ownership Using shareholder voting rights and engagement to influence corporate behavior on ESG issues.

These approaches aren't mutually exclusive—many ESG investors employ multiple strategies simultaneously to achieve their financial and impact objectives.

Potential Benefits of ESG Investing

1. Risk Management ESG analysis can identify non-financial risks that might eventually translate into financial liabilities, regulatory penalties, or reputational damage.

2. Long-Term Performance Companies with strong ESG practices may be better positioned to navigate industry transitions, regulatory changes, and shifting consumer preferences.

3. Innovation Opportunities Sustainability challenges can drive innovation, creating new markets and competitive advantages for solution providers.

4. Values Alignment ESG investing enables individuals to align their investments with their personal or institutional values while still participating in financial markets.

5. Positive Impact Collectively, ESG investors can influence capital flows toward companies addressing critical environmental and social challenges.

Key Considerations and Limitations

1. Data Quality and Standardization ESG reporting lacks universal standards, making comparisons between companies challenging.

2. Greenwashing Risk Some companies may exaggerate their sustainability credentials or make misleading claims about their ESG performance.

3. Performance Debates While some studies show positive or neutral relationships between ESG factors and returns, results vary by sector, time period, and methodology.

4. Trade-offs Investors may face trade-offs between different ESG priorities (e.g., a company with strong environmental practices but governance concerns).

5. Implementation Costs Some ESG strategies may involve higher research costs or fees compared to conventional approaches.

Through thoughtful consideration of these factors, investors can develop ESG strategies that align with both their values and financial goals, creating portfolios that aim to benefit people, planet, and profits.

Investment Ideas for All Budgets

For Small Investors (1 to 100 Dollars)

Fractional Shares of ESG ETFs

Description: Fractional investing allows access to diversified ESG-focused ETFs with minimal capital, providing instant exposure to dozens or hundreds of companies screened for environmental, social, and governance factors.

Advantages:

• Low entry point with some brokerages offering $1 minimum investments

• Immediate diversification across multiple companies and sectors

• Professional ESG screening and monitoring

• Lower risk than selecting individual ESG stocks

• Regular rebalancing as ESG criteria and company performance evolve

Limitations:

• Limited control over specific ESG criteria or priorities

• Potential mismatch between personal values and fund methodology

• Higher expense ratios than non-ESG index funds (typically)

Implementation:

• Research low-cost ESG ETFs like ESGU (iShares ESG Aware MSCI USA ETF), ESGV (Vanguard ESG U.S. Stock ETF), or SUSL (iShares ESG MSCI USA Leaders ETF)

• Compare expense ratios and ESG methodologies to find the best match for your priorities

• Set up regular automatic investments, even with small amounts

• Enable dividend reinvestment to compound returns

For Medium Investors (101 to 10,000 Dollars)

Thematic ESG Portfolio

Description: A mid-sized budget allows for creating a more customized portfolio combining broad ESG ETFs with thematic investments focusing on specific sustainability challenges like clean energy, water management, or gender diversity.

Advantages:

• More targeted exposure to specific ESG themes you're passionate about

• Ability to weight your portfolio toward environmental, social, or governance priorities

• Potential to capture growth in emerging sustainability solutions

• Flexibility to adjust allocations as sustainability trends evolve

Limitations:

• Thematic funds often carry higher expense ratios

• Concentrated thematic exposure may increase volatility

• Requires more research and ongoing monitoring

• Some themes may experience significant sector bias

Implementation:

• Allocate 50-70% to core ESG ETFs for broad market exposure

• Dedicate 30-50% to 2-4 thematic funds aligned with your priorities, such as:

  • Clean energy (ICLN, QCLN, PBW)

  • Water (FIW, PHO)

  • Gender diversity (SHE, WOMN)

  • Low carbon (CRBN, LOWC)

• Rebalance annually to maintain desired allocations

• Consider a tax-advantaged account for more frequent trading of thematic positions

For Large Investors (10,000 Dollars and Above)

Customized Multi-Asset ESG Strategy

Description: With larger capital, investors can implement sophisticated ESG approaches across asset classes, potentially including direct stock ownership, green bonds, sustainable real estate, and even private market impact investments.

Advantages:

• Ability to create a truly personalized ESG strategy aligned with specific values

• Access to institutional-class ESG funds with lower expense ratios

• Potential to include less liquid but high-impact investments

• Opportunity for tax optimization across various account types

• Can implement active ownership through proxy voting and engagement

Limitations:

• Increased complexity requires more research and potentially professional guidance

• Higher minimum investments for certain specialized funds or private market opportunities

• More time-intensive to manage and monitor

• Challenging to ensure consistency of ESG approach across diverse holdings

Implementation:

• Core allocation (50-60%): ESG-integrated public equities across market caps and geographies

• Fixed income allocation (20-30%): Green bonds, social bonds, and sustainability-linked bonds

• Alternative allocation (10-20%): Consider sustainable REITs, renewable energy yieldcos, or impact-focused interval funds

• For qualified investors: Explore private market impact funds focusing on areas like affordable housing, community development, or climate solutions

• Create a personal "ESG policy statement" defining your priorities and exclusions

• Consider working with an advisor specializing in sustainable investing for optimal implementation

Educational Corner: Understanding ESG Ratings

ESG ratings are scores assigned to companies by specialized research firms to assess environmental, social, and governance performance. These ratings can help investors compare companies, but understanding their methodology and limitations is crucial:

1. Major ESG Rating Providers

   • MSCI ESG Research

   • Sustainalytics (owned by Morningstar)

   • S&P Global ESG Scores

   • Bloomberg ESG Data

   • ISS ESG

2. How Ratings Work

   • Collect data from corporate disclosures, government sources, NGOs, and media

   • Analyze hundreds of indicators across E, S, and G dimensions

   • Weight factors based on industry materiality (e.g., water usage is more critical for beverage companies than software firms)

   • Compare companies against industry peers rather than absolute standards

   • Assign final ratings, often on scales like AAA-CCC (MSCI) or 0-100 (Sustainalytics)

3. Limitations to Consider

   • Divergent Methodologies: Different rating agencies often produce contradictory assessments of the same company

   • Size Bias: Larger companies with more resources for sustainability reporting tend to receive higher ratings

   • Disclosure vs. Performance: Ratings sometimes reward disclosure quality more than actual sustainability outcomes

   • Backward-Looking: Most ratings primarily reflect past performance rather than future potential or transition strategies

   • Industry Relativism: "Best-in-class" approaches mean a high-rated oil company is still an oil company

4. Using Ratings Effectively

   • Understand the methodology behind the ratings you reference

   • Consider consulting multiple rating sources when evaluating investments

   • Look beyond the headline score to component ratings in areas you prioritize

   • Use ratings as a starting point for analysis, not the final word

   • Review the reasoning behind controversial ratings to form your own assessment

By understanding both the value and limitations of ESG ratings, investors can use these tools effectively as part of a more comprehensive sustainable investing approach.

Did You Know?

During the market turbulence of 2020, 65% of ESG-focused large-cap equity funds outperformed their conventional counterparts, according to Morningstar research. This challenges the persistent myth that sustainable investing necessarily involves sacrificing returns. In fact, companies with strong ESG practices often demonstrated greater resilience during the crisis, benefiting from more loyal customers, more engaged employees, more flexible supply chains, and better risk management. While past performance doesn't guarantee future results, this period highlighted how ESG factors can potentially enhance financial performance, particularly during times of market stress and rapid change.

That concludes this article of How to Invest. ESG investing offers a powerful framework for aligning your portfolio with your values while still pursuing competitive financial returns. Whether you're just starting with fractional shares of ESG ETFs or implementing a sophisticated multi-asset sustainable strategy, considering environmental, social, and governance factors alongside traditional financial metrics can help build resilience into your investments while contributing to positive change. As sustainable investing continues to evolve, staying informed about ESG methodologies, data improvements, and emerging opportunities will be key to successful implementation.